Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elisabeth Bromberg's avatar

Your first scenario probably draws me in the most, because it has the structure of an org without the bureaucratic weight/political overhead of one. I'm reading this as mapping on to the workforce model that the BCG piece describes inside "AI Abundance." But then my question of course is "how does this actually come to life," and the BCG piece has a really interesting (and admittedly terrifying) answer to that. Their path to AI Abundance runs through a crisis aka a series of AI-enabled cyberattacks on critical infrastructure that basically forces governments into a binding multilateral regulatory approach, which has to happen BEFORE the social safety nets, four-day work weeks, etc.

So I guess where I get stuck is that I can imagine the scenarios, but I wonder whether the futures that require regulation, redistribution, restraint etc from those currently holding power can get built WITHOUT the kind of rupture none of us actually want to live through. And even then, I'm not sure we're moving towards a future where a rupture would break the way we need it to. The BCG scenario assumes a crisis bad enough to force coordinated regulatory response, but that also assumes that the institutional etc capacity to coordinate still exists when/if a crisis hits. Right now the US is dismantling those conditions. Trump's December executive order used federal funding to limit state AI regulation, and I'd be shocked if this admin ratifies the Council of Europe AI Framework Convention that the US signed under Biden. So if we keep dismantling those conditions, a forcing event could produce MORE fragmentation, not less. And my fear is that would bend the trajectory toward Digital Darwinism, not Abundance.

Looking forward to Part 2...and wondering if what we need to sit with goes beyond the types of orgs we want in 2036, and into whether the political conditions to build them by design still exist. And whether a rupture could even produce the right kind of response anymore.

No posts

Ready for more?